Shoulder and Arm Injury Car Accident Settlements
If you have suffered a personal injury to your arm or shoulder in a car accident, it is natural to wonder what type of settlement you might receive in a claim or lawsuit. The purpose of this article is to review the major considerations in shoulder and arm personal injury cases, and to cover recent settlements and verdicts in these cases.
Types of Arm and Shoulder Injuries in Car Accidents
Shoulder injuries and upper arm injuries are common in car accidents. The shoulder is highly complex; injuries to this area are not always properly diagnosed immediately following the accident. However, many accident victims suffer from shoulder pain after car, motorcycle and bike accidents. The heavy trauma to that small area from the accident can cause many serious shoulder injuries.
There are several common shoulder injuries in car accidents. Usually, injuries to the shoulder involve the ligaments, tendons and muscles and not to the shoulder joint. However, some fractures of the upper arm and the shoulder joint have occurred in car accidents.
Should injuries are classified in two ways. The first type is an instability injury where a shoulder joint is improperly aligned. This injury will cause pain when you raise the arm, or the shoulder will slip out of place. The other type of shoulder injury in a car accident is referred to as impingement. This is where your shoulder muscles rub on the shoulder blade top. Impingement is often caused by repetitive motion, but it can be the result of a car accident. Below is more information about specific shoulder injuries.
A fracture of your clavicle or humerous can be caused by a direct hit to the area in an accident or fall. Most shoulder fractures must be diagnosed with X-rays. However, a CT scan may also be needed to process a personal injury claim.
- In a fracture of the clavicle, mid collarbone swelling is clear. This area may appear to have a bump in it, which is the end of the fracture below your skin. The range of motion in the shoulder will be limited, but not as much as a proximal humerous fracture.
- For a fracture of the proximal humerous, the shoulder will be very swollen, as the effects are upon a larger bone than the clavicle. You will have a very limited range of motion, with severe pain.
Dislocation is common in the acromioclavicular joint. This is the point where the collarbone meets the highest aspect of the shoulder blade. A dislocation is common in both car accidents and falls.
Rotator Cuff Tear
Soft tissue injuries to the shoulder include damage to the muscles, joint, tendon and joint capsule. Shoulder injuries such as rotator cuff tears in car accidents are more common than injuries to the joint or bones. However, diagnosis of this injury can be problematic. An MRI can confirm a diagnosis, but your doctor will need to show proper correlation of pain to the actual injury. The pain with this type of injury will usually be in the front of your shoulder and go down your arm. You could feel the pain when you sleep on your side.
A related soft tissue injury is a SLAP tear, which is to the shoulder labrum. This is a cartilage ring that is around the shoulder socket. SLAP is the acronym for Superior Labrum Anterior and Posterior. This injury can be suspected when you have less range of motion and less strength, as well as significant pain with movement.
Arm and Shoulder Injury Symptoms
The shoulder is a type of ball and socket joint with three major bones. These bones are the scapula, clavicle and humerous (arm bone). All of the bones are joined at the shoulder joint by ligaments, muscles, tendons and the joint capsule. When functioning normally, the shoulder joint has the largest range of motion in the body. This mobility has advantages, but it also means the joint is more prone to injury in violent accidents.
After a car accident, it is important to take note if you are suffering from any shoulder pain. Recovery from a shoulder injury can take months and it is critical to have it diagnosed as soon as possible. Some of the most common shoulder and arm injury symptoms to watch for are:
- Stiff and tender shoulder that hurts the most at night; sleep is often difficult
- Lack of feeling, weakness, inflammation in the shoulder
- Physical exertion makes shoulder pain worse
- Difficulty moving the arm in any direction without pain
- Concentrated, focused pain in the shoulder joint
- Shoulder appears bruised or pale
How Shoulder and Arm Injuries Are Valued
Valuing a shoulder or arm injury personal injury claim means arriving at a reasonable ‘guesstimate’ of what a jury would award to you in a lawsuit. Also under consideration is what the plaintiff to the lawsuit would agree to pay. The plaintiff in such cases usually is a car insurance company. There also will be questions about what each side would consider offering to get the case resolved before an expensive trial.
The major factors in valuing any shoulder and arm injury case is how severe your damages are, and what the chances are the jury would find the defendant liable when/if the case goes to court.
However, estimating what you could receive in a car accident shoulder surgery settlement or car accident rotator cuff surgery settlement can be challenging for one big reason: During a trial, it is usually the jury that will decide the amount of money the insurance company or defendant must pay you.
Some shoulder and arm injury damages – such as lost earnings and medical costs – are simple to predict. These losses are usually the amount that you can show you have paid/lost, and will keep paying/losing as you recover. But for subjective pain and suffering damages, predictions of a settlement amount are just a guess. This guess is based upon research of past awards that were won in previous arm and shoulder injury cases. But every personal injury case and jury varies. So even the most educated analysis by a personal injury attorney of your pain and suffering damages could be off by a significant margin. Why is this?
Many arm and shoulder injuries will affect different plaintiffs differently. For example, if you are an active golfer and you played 18 holes every Saturday, perhaps your shoulder impingement or rotator cuff injury prevents you from enjoying this activity. The damages incurred for pain and suffering in this type of case might be higher than a person who was sedentary before the car accident.
If you had an earlier shoulder injury, such as rotator cuff surgery, that the accident makes more likely to recur, it is possible you could receive a lower settlement. Also, if the arm or shoulder injury prevents you from earning your living, the defendant may be responsible for years of lost or reduced wages.
The other major issue regarding the value of the shoulder and arm injury settlement is how likely the other person would be found negligent at the trial. If there is little evidence that the other person caused the accident, the value of your shoulder injury drops. Even if the chances of a higher settlement are great, the defendant could be willing to go to trial to try to prevail and pay little or nothing. And if fault is unclear, the plaintiff may want to settle as there is a chance of getting nothing from a jury.
Average Shoulder and Arm Injury Settlement
Here is some real settlement and verdict information for various shoulder and arm injuries from car accidents. Talk to a personal injury attorney, however, to get better idea what your car accident injury is worth:
- Median verdict and settlement for torn rotator cuff cases in Fulton County, Georgia: $72,500
- Median verdict and settlement for torn rotator cuff cases in all of Georgia: $25,000
- $100,000: Client in Georgia had car hit in rear end at high speed by someone without insurance. This led to a complete rotator cuff tear. The case was worth more, but the limits of insurance coverage was reached at $100,000. This is a good example why people should buy as much uninsured motorist coverage they can afford.
- $737,000: A plaintiff in Illinois was rear ended, and the liability for the case was clear. The initial offer from the insurance company was only $190,000. The attorney on the case used a vocational rehabilitation specialist to show the level of work restriction and lost wages, resulting in a much higher settlement.
Shoulder and Arm Injury Summary
Insurance companies are fond of denying personal injury claims for these injuries. The company may claim that you had a previous injury to the shoulder. But the best way to beat this argument is to get medical treatment immediately after the accident. Even if you do not feel significant pain after an accident, you should be evaluated by a medical professional right away. You could experience shoulder pain a few hours or days after the accident. Whether you get compensation for this injury often hinges on a prompt medical evaluation.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Can you get a rotator cuff injury from a car accident?
Do not believe what the car insurance company tells you. You can certainly get a tear in a rotator cuff from a car accident! A torn rotator cuff is a very painful and debilitating injury that can limit your shoulder’s range of motion. Completing daily tasks can become an exercise in torture. Unfortunately, a torn rotator cuff is a very common injury from all types of car accidents, including rear end collisions.
A tear in the rotator cuff happens when one of the four tendons are injured, either from wear and tear, or in a violent collision such as a car accident. Insurance companies like to try to claim that a torn rotator cuff is only from wear and tear, but this is nonsense. It is clear by a complete medical examination by a medical professional when a torn rotator cuff is caused by a car accident or other type of collision.
Any type of car crash can cause this injury, but it is especially common with the rear end crash. If you think you are about to be hit from behind, you may tense up and grab the steering wheel. Your shoulder is tensed, and if it is, it is entirely possible for the force of the accident to be transmitted into the shoulder and rotator cuff.
Only your doctor can diagnose a torn rotator cuff, and their findings are crucial to your claim. But if you have these symptoms after a car accident, you might have this serious shoulder injury:
- Severe and/or sudden pain to the top or outside part of the shoulder
- Pain that radiates through the arm
- Reduced motion
- Difficulty sleeping because of pressure on the shoulder
- Popping or clicking of the shoulder when you move your arm
Can shoulder bursitis be caused by a car accident?
Many people have shoulder problems after they are in a car accident. The trauma to your shoulder joint due to the high impact of a car crash can cause a variety of shoulder injuries, including bursitis. Bursitis in the shoulder is essentially an inflamed shoulder bursa. The bursa is a sac filled with fluid that helps to reduce friction in the shoulder. It is common for the bursa sac to be damaged in a car accident.
Your shoulder is a ball and socket joint with three major bones, which are held in place by tendons, ligaments and muscles. The shoulder joint usually has the greatest range of motion in your body. Because of the range of motion, this joint is more easily injured than others.
After a car accident, if you have pain in the shoulder, this is a warning sign that you should have it checked out right away. Some of the common types of pain that can indicate a serious shoulder injury, including bursitis, are:
- Tingling, weakness, numbness and swelling in the shoulder
- Shoulder pain in a certain spot that can get worse when you exert yourself
- Difficulty moving the arm in any way without pain
- Sudden, serious pain in your shoulder
- A pale, blue or discolored shoulder
One of the common types of shoulder injury after a car accident is frozen shoulder. This is where the injury from the car accident leads to pain and inflammation that eventually limits your ability to move the joint. It is common for bursitis to form in the shoulder after a car accident and cause this limited range of motion.
If you stop moving the shoulder much for several weeks due to bursitis, the tissue in the shoulder will get thicker and shrink. This will cause pain and make you move the shoulder less. This is a vicious cycle that can lead to long term disability.
What’s the average car accident settlement for arm & shoulder injuries?
Shoulder injuries in car accidents can be serious and very painful. They can often prevent you from doing your work and various activities that you enjoy. While the shoulder has the most free range motion of any joint in the body, it is easily damaged in a car accident or other type of accident.
Shoulder injuries can range from a dislocated shoulder and torn ligaments, to a torn rotator cuff, to a shoulder fracture, or simply a severely broken arm. More specifically, you could have a fracture of the collar bone, humerous or top of the upper arm bone or scapula or shoulder blade.
Another serious shoulder injury that can lead to a large settlement is a dislocation of the collar bone; this is also known as a separated shoulder. Another type of dislocation is of the sternoclavicular joint between the sternum and clavicle. The glenohumeral joint also can be dislocated, which is the ball and socket joint of the shoulder.
How much an arm and shoulder injury personal injury settlement will be dependent upon many factors that vary widely. Some of the factors to determine the settlement value are:
- Whether any tear in the shoulder ligaments and tissue was full or partial
- Whether you needed surgery on your arm or shoulder
- How well you healed after the surgery
- How well your injury responded to physical therapy
- How much work time you missed
- Whether you were able to regain full range of motion; if you have a permanent disability, this will increase the settlement value
- Whether the arm or shoulder was on your dominant side
Some arm and shoulder injuries on the less serious side can range from $10,000 to $25,000, if the injury generally heals well and missed work time is less. But for more serious, long term injuries, settlements of $75,000 to $100,000 or more are not uncommon.
Can shoulder impingement be caused by a car accident?
Shoulder impingement after a car accident is one of the most frequent shoulder injuries. Shoulder impingement can restrict your ability to move your shoulder and can cause weakness and pain when you reach for and lift things.
While other body joints have bones that are surrounded by muscles and tendons, the shoulder is unique. It has muscles and tendons that are also surrounded by bones. The muscles of your rotator cuff are between the head of your upper arm bone or humerous and the bony projection on your shoulder blade called the acromion.
Impingement can happen when the tendons of your rotator cuff rub against these bones. This can be caused by repetitive motions, but also can be caused by the violent forces of a car accident. A common car accident scenario is if you see in your rear view mirror that you are about to be hit from behind. It is natural to grip the steering wheel and tense up. When the collision occurs, some of that impact can be transferred into the delicate shoulder joint, causing rotator cuff damage and/or joint impingement.
Some of the common symptoms of impingement after a car accident include:
- Pain when you reach over your head
- Pain when you try to reach behind you
- Muscle weakness in the shoulder when trying to lift something
- Shoulder pain that radiates from the front of the shoulder to the side of the arm
- Swelling or tenderness in the front part of the shoulder
It is important to know that shoulder impingement is common after car accidents and it will get progressively worse without treatment. Your range of motion may decline as time goes by. That is why it is so important to have a doctor look you over as soon as possible after the accident.
Can whiplash affect your shoulder?
Whiplash is a soft tissue injury causing muscle and ligament strains, typically known for affecting your neck and spine. However, whiplash injuries, particularly severe ones, are known for expanding symptoms beyond the neck. It is very possible to experience shoulder pain in the case of a severe whiplash injury. Depending on many different factors such as, what type of accident you were involved in (t-bone, rear-end), or how the safety restraints restricted you from moving can influence how your body is affected by the whiplash. If you are experiencing whiplash after a collision, you may also be experiencing shoulder pain known as Impingement Syndrome. This happens when your tendon rubs against your shoulder blade causing irritation, swelling and pain. The backward and sudden forward motion that causes whiplash may also cause pain to areas below your neck and shoulders.
What’s the average settlement for a torn labrum?
Car accidents cause many injuries to all areas of the body. One common shoulder injury you may sustain from a car accident is a torn labrum. The labrum is the cartilage tissue attached and surrounding your shoulder socket to help keep the ball of the joint set in place. A torn labrum can require surgery and a painful, lengthy recovery. There is no exact amount a victim of a torn labrum can except due to many variables that are unique to each individual case. Some examples of settlements received for a torn labrum include:
- $315,000- car accident resulting in torn tendons and torn labrum requiring surgery and 8 week recovery timeframe
- $275,000- car accident resulting in torn labrum along with other injuries, requiring surgery.
- $300,000- car accident suffering torn labrum, torn tendons and rotator cuff requiring surgery.
How much should a settlement be for a rotator cuff surgery?
There are many different types of shoulder injuries with a wide range of severity from a torn rotator cuff to broken bones and fractures. In the case of a shoulder injury, it is very common to see torn rotator cuffs and unfortunately, is common that rotator cuff injuries may require surgery. If untreated by surgery, it is possible that it will not heal and will remain torn. When determining how much a settlement should be also has many factors that help decide how much a victim should be owed. Some factors that go into determining the case value include:
- How severe was the tear?
- Was surgery required?
- How long was the recovery time?
- Pain and suffering
- What was the physical therapy process like?
- Compensation for loss of wages
- Was the shoulder able to fully recover?
Some examples of real settlement verdicts of torn rotator cuff injuries that required surgery include:
- $190,000- bus accident resulting in torn rotator cuff requiring surgery
- $250,000- rear-end collision resulting in torn rotator cuff requiring surgery
- $340,000- left turn collision resulting in torn rotator cuff requiring surgery
- $300,000- struck by vehicle walking on the side of the road resulting in torn rotator cuff requiring surgery
What type of payout can I expect for shoulder surgery after a car accident?
If you have injured your shoulder and needed surgery from being involved in a car accident, you can expect a large settlement value. Once again, determining how much the settlement value is worth has many different variables to be considered while coming up with a value. Shoulder injuries that require surgery result in a higher payout than injuries that don’t require surgery. Some settlement examples include:
- $170,000- shoulder injury requiring surgery caused by trucking accident
- $250,000- shoulder injury requiring surgery resulting from car accident
- $275,000- shoulder injury/multiple other injuries requiring surgery resulting from car accident
- $250,000- torn rotator cuff requiring surgery
- $689,000- torn rotator cuff requiring surgery resulting in loss of his job